APPEAL AND RECONSIDER YOUR DECESION
Baldev Raj Mahi, S/o Sh. Ram Asra,
Nawanshahar (Pb)
Ex-Manager,
Dated: 20-03
Baba Deep Singh Nagar,
Saloh Road,
Backside K.C.Palace, Nawanshahr (Punjab)
Distt. Sahid Bhagat Singh Nagar
Sh G . S DUBEY
THE GENERAL MANAGER
(APPELLATE AUTHORITY)
PERSONAL ADMINSTRATION DIVISION.
Punjab National Bank,
Head Office, 7, Bhikaiji Cama Place,
New Delhi-110066
R/Sir
REF: MY PERSONAL REQUEST TO YOUR GOOD SELF ON PHONE DATE 26-10 ON THE OCCASION OF DIWALI .
Reg: Appeal under Regulation 17 of D & A Regulations, 1977 in the matter of Charge Sheet dated 05-10 served upon me under Regulation 6 of D & A Regulations, 1977 by the Deputy General Manager (Disciplinary Authority), Punjab National Bank, Circle Office, Hoshiarpur, against the impugned orders of punishment vide No. COH/HRD/I/BRM/2298 dated 06-07, served upon me by the Assistant General Manager, (Disciplinary Authority), Circle Office, Hoshiarpur thereby inflicting the major penalty under Regulation 4 (h) of D & A Regulations, 1977.
RESPECTFULLY IT IS SUBMITTED THAT I TALKED TO YOUR GOOD SELF ON PHONE ON THE AFORCESAID SUBJECT . I AM VERY THANKFULL TO YOU FOR GIVING ME A PATIENT HEARING ON PHONE . IT HAS GIVEN ME A HOPE THAT MY CASE WILL BE CONSIDERED ON MERIT, SYMPATHETIC AND HUMANTRIAN GROUNDS.
I SUBMIT AS UNDER FOR KIND PERUSAL AND AS FAVOURABLE CONSIDERATION
Respectfully, it is submitted to consider as under:-
That the Deputy General Manager, the then (Disciplinary Authority), Circle Head, Hoshiarpur has served upon me Charge Sheet dated 05-10 under Regulation 6 of D & A Regulations, 1977 for the alleged lapses while I was working as Manager at BO Usmanpur and thereafter, he had also passed an order for regular enquiry proceedings.
That after conclusion of regular hearings and after receipt of enquiry report of the Inquiry Officer, the Assistant General Manager, now (Disciplinary Authority), Circle Office, Hoshiarpur has passed the final order vide No. COH/HRD/I/BRM/2298 dated 06-07 and inflicted the punishment under Regulation 4 (h) of compulsory retirement. The said impugned order dated 06-07-11 was served upon me on 16-07-11.
That being aggrieved from the disproportionate, harsh and shocking punishment to the conscious of a reasonable man, I prefer an Appeal under Regulation 17 of D & A Regulations, 1977 wherein there is a provision that such Appeal should be filed within the stipulated period of 45 days or alternatively to seek extension under Regulation 21 of D & A Regulations, 1977. In the present case, the period of 45 days was expiring on 29-08 and in apprehension that I may not be able to prefer the Appeal within the stipulated period of 45 days, I had further moved a separate application/representation on 23-08 thereby seeking extension under Regulation 21 of D & A Regulations, 1977 upto 14-09 which has not been responded adversely. In the light of my all these submissions, I hereunder prefer this Appeal within the period of extension upto 14-09 and thus, the Appeal is in order for favourable consideration. The issues in Appeal are as under:-
18. That my case was not considered on humanitarian grounds.
That I always received meritorious and appreciation letters for my working as Incumbent Incharge.
That my track record has been unblemished.
That I had already put clean and clear service of 27 years in the bank and thus, it was necessary to see my track record of 27 years period.
That there is no fraud in any of the cases except at the most may be foolish bonafide inadvertent procedural lapse, if any.
That my wife has since been expired after prolonged expensive illness.
That I have no son to take care of my family affairs.
That I have three daughters for their education and marriage.
That I am suffering from the disease of Flaria which is uncureable.
That I have no other source of income.
That I do not have any past savings or funds in any shape or form or even I am not in a position to continue my family members with food, clothing, education, medical care and to discharge all other social and substantial and subsistent requirements for survival and to live with honour and dignity in the society.
All sympathies as human being are required.
That I was not the only person in the branch whereas all other officials have been exonerated for the same course of lapses and only I have been discriminated in the matter.
Due to un substantiated charges I and my whole family remained tense, and due to paucity of funds I could not provide proper treatment to my wife and to my self. Due to tension in my family my wife died in the prime of her youth. My family life is fully destroyed due to tension in my family. There was also a loss to the education of my children due to paucity of funds. On the wrong report of Sh. G.L Sharma senior Manager I was also defamed in the society. Due to the un timely death of my wife even my small kids have to go to bed without proper food. Because of prejudiced behaviour of some senior officers my whole career has been spoilt. The whole work and increase in the business done by me in this branch has been down graded. I was expecting promotion from this branch but I got tarnished. I achieved all targets which were always appreciated by higher authorities which were never met previously in this loss making branch.
Prayer
1. Than an opportunity of personal hearing may kindly be accorded under the principles of natural justice, even if the same is not provided under any of the Regulations, so that I may be heard properly, patiently and sympathetically.
2. That a lenient view may kindly be taken in the matter because at this age of about 50 years, I am unable to get employment anywhere whereas my wife has already expired, I have three daughters who are school and college going requiring financial assistance for their education and marriage whereas I am already suffering from Flaria in my leg which is un-cureble in the medical science. I have no other source of income whatsoever it may be and at the same time, I do not have any deposits or saved earnings in the past because lot of expenditure was incurred on the treatment of my wife etc.,
3. That the order of ‘compulsory retirement’ is extremely disproportionate, unreasoned, harsh, shocking to the conscious of a reasonable man keeping in view that I have not been a beneficiary, there is no fraud case and the bank has not suffered any financial loss. Thus, the punishment is liable to be modified as reduced.
4. You are requested to change your unwarranted and wrong decision which was imposed by forcefully without any base or any evidence.
Yours faithfully,
(B.R.Mahi)
(BALDEV RAJ MAHI)
PF NO . 52135
MANAGER PNB, LDM OFFICE HOSHIARPUR (PUNJAB)
0 comments